Example: There is a company in the food production industry who is in need of a new Operations Director. This director is supposed to have the following qualifications and experience:
- 20 years of experience in the food industry of which 10 years in a management position
- Not older than 45 years
- Having a black belt in Six Sigma
- Speaking English plus at least 2 further European languages fluently
- And who goes once a week to the hairdresser to colour his/her hair in pink.
The perversion about the UK labour market is, and possibly any other labour market, a headhunter will find exactly this person, and not only one specimen but at least 5 for a shortlist.
I do see the point from a headhunter's view - "client wants, client gets" and of course, being in the service industry myself, that's the leitmotif of all of us. What I am concerned about though is that this is a sheer tick box exercise. I have had so many phone calls from headhunters who literally tick off their list and then they send your CV off. Nobody ever asks about the candidate's personality or what he does in his spare time, what hobbies he has, etc. And the result can be, that a robot who fulfils all those criteria, but who has the personality of a Bernadine dog gets the job rather than someone who is also suitable, but who probably does not exactly match all those requirements.
If someone wants to change his career and do something completely different, it will be a drag to find any job, because ticking the box does not leave any room for manoeuvre for any candidate. There is always someone who ticks all those boxes and the one who only meets a few criteria does not stand a chance.
I am currently in a similar position. Say, I wanted to apply for the role above, and taking away the pink hair bit, I would never get the job even though I know everything about production, tick off many of the criteria, and am sure I would do a great job. In the end, I have "only" been a consultant but never done the management bit of the position, hence I will never get the chance of even getting invited.
This is clearly frustrating and sometimes I could scream, especially when getting a short e-mail from a headhunter telling me how great I am, but unfortunately not great enough. But okay, that's how things go and I don't want to sound like a frustrated housewife. Rant over!
- 20 years of experience in the food industry of which 10 years in a management position
- Not older than 45 years
- Having a black belt in Six Sigma
- Speaking English plus at least 2 further European languages fluently
- And who goes once a week to the hairdresser to colour his/her hair in pink.
The perversion about the UK labour market is, and possibly any other labour market, a headhunter will find exactly this person, and not only one specimen but at least 5 for a shortlist.
I do see the point from a headhunter's view - "client wants, client gets" and of course, being in the service industry myself, that's the leitmotif of all of us. What I am concerned about though is that this is a sheer tick box exercise. I have had so many phone calls from headhunters who literally tick off their list and then they send your CV off. Nobody ever asks about the candidate's personality or what he does in his spare time, what hobbies he has, etc. And the result can be, that a robot who fulfils all those criteria, but who has the personality of a Bernadine dog gets the job rather than someone who is also suitable, but who probably does not exactly match all those requirements.
If someone wants to change his career and do something completely different, it will be a drag to find any job, because ticking the box does not leave any room for manoeuvre for any candidate. There is always someone who ticks all those boxes and the one who only meets a few criteria does not stand a chance.
I am currently in a similar position. Say, I wanted to apply for the role above, and taking away the pink hair bit, I would never get the job even though I know everything about production, tick off many of the criteria, and am sure I would do a great job. In the end, I have "only" been a consultant but never done the management bit of the position, hence I will never get the chance of even getting invited.
This is clearly frustrating and sometimes I could scream, especially when getting a short e-mail from a headhunter telling me how great I am, but unfortunately not great enough. But okay, that's how things go and I don't want to sound like a frustrated housewife. Rant over!
No comments:
Post a Comment